top of page
b39a4169-a658-4f74-8ee4-27919c3b5ac3.jpeg
MaysButton1b.png
MaysFudgeLogoNew.png
MaysButton2b.png
OrderALaCarteRibbon4b.png
DealsAndSpecials.png
HistoricalPhoto3b.png
HaroldMayMakingFudge11b.png
MaysFudgemakers6b.png
MaysHistoricStore1b.png
MaysTheChoiceofPresidents2b.png
NewMaysPhoto5b.png
TheMayFamilyTradition.png
MaysFudgeHistoricalPhoto.jpeg

Why is May’s Fudge the real true original fudge store on Mackinac Island?

DealsAndSpecials.png
CandyCollectionsHeader.png
ComingSoonButton2b.png
DealsAndHeadersHeader2b.png
ComingSoonButton2b.png
MissionStatementHeader.png

Curate Your Signature Gift Collection

IMG_3763.jpeg

An Elevated Taste of Mackinac Island:

Design a refined, one-of-a-kind gift featuring our hand-paddled fudge, golden brittles, buttery toffee, and gourmet caramel corn — all made in small batches on historic Mackinac Island. Each selection is elegantly packaged and customizable for any occasion, from client gifts to personal indulgence.

Exquisite flavors. Elegant presentation. Exclusively Mackinac.

Exceptional Corporate Gifting

IMG_3762.jpeg

Distinctive Sweets for Discerning Clients:

Leave a lasting impression with premium, handcrafted confections from Michigan’s most iconic island. Our fudge and candy gifts convey quality, gratitude, and attention to detail — perfect for executive appreciation, corporate milestones, and hospitality events.

Call for bespoke corporate packages and reliable delivery nationwide.

Elevate your gifting with the heritage and craftsmanship of Mackinac Island.

Legacy of Craftsmanship
For Decades

IMG_3772.jpeg

Where Tradition Meets Taste:

For decades, we’ve been perfecting the art of Mackinac Island fudge. Each small batch is crafted with all-natural, ingredients — including Michigan Sugar, fresh cream, and locally harvested cherries — delivering a velvety smooth texture and an unmistakably pure flavor.

Our fudge isn’t just candy — it’s an edible piece of Michigan history.

Indulge in the timeless luxury of authentic Mackinac Island fudge.

Weddings & Celebrations with Island Elegance

IMG_3765.jpeg

Sweet Favors for Unforgettable Moments:

Enhance your wedding or event with elegant fudge favors and gourmet dessert displays that reflect the beauty and charm of Mackinac Island. Choose from a variety of flavors and presentation styles, including custom 3x3-inch favor boxes and full-service  catering experiences.

Celebrate love, tradition, and taste — one perfect piece of fudge at a time.

bottom of page